03 March 2011

Research Notes: Dick & Butcher Families, Part 3

Sorry, I took a little break from posting more of my research notes as my computer recently crashed and I’ve been spending a lot of my free time trying to install all the programs and software to get it up and running again. (Luckily, I didn’t lose any of my genealogy files).






“McComas/ Qualls Family” Tree, submitted by ancestry.com user, “JRVS5156”:

“Notley T. Dick Birth abt 1827 in Virginia Death in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA

married to Catherine Cyrus Birth 1830 in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA Death in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA

Daughter of James Cyrus Birth 1790 in ,,Virginia,USA Death 1855-12 in Cyrus Creek,Cabell,Virginia,USA

and Sarah Birth 1795 in ,,Virginia,USA Death in Cabell,,West Virginia,USA

Siblings of Catherine Cyrus:

1. Sarah Cyrus Birth in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA Death in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA, married to John Martin

2. Margaret Cyrus Birth abt 2 Feb 1812 in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA Death 7 Jul 1857 in Waters Mud, Cabell, Virginia, USA married to Joseph Newman 1803 – 1865

3. Elijah Cyrus Birth 1818 in Putnam Co,, Virginia, USA Death 11 Feb 1885 in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA married to Mary Margaret Wentz 1828 – 1901

4. Elizabeth Cyrus Birth 1828 in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA Death abt 1864 in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA

5. (Catherine Cyrus)

6. William Henry Cyrus Birth 1834 in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA Death 11 Feb 1885 in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA married to Sarilda McComas 1836 – 1924

7. Nancy Cyrus Birth 1835 in Cabell,,Virginia,USA Death 3 Feb 1855 in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA

8. Matilda Cyrus Birth 1841 in Cabell,,Virginia,USA Death in Cabell, , West Virginia, USA married to George McComas 1836 – 1919

9. Mary Cyrus Birth 1843 in Cabell,,Virginia,USA”



____________________________________________________________________





“CLEDA R STEPHENS FAMILY RESEARCH” family tree, submitted by ancestry.com user “Cleda45” of Cabell County, West Virginia:

“Joseph Dick Birth 1800 in Virginia, Death 1875 in LIN CO WV

Marriage to Eleanor Butcher abt 1852

1860 Residence Cabell, Virginia

Marriage to Catherine Cook

Eleanor Butcher’s father: William Butcher Birth 1771

Children of Joseph Dick and Eleanor Butcher:

1. David Dick

2. Natley Dick Birth 1825

3. Andrew Jackson Dick Birth 1827 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA, 1851, 1st Marriage to Cynthia A Leonard 2 Jan 1851 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA, 2nd Marriage to Mary V Handley 28 Nov 1864 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA, Death 1880 in , Cabell, West Virginia, USA

4. Joseph Dick Birth 1827 in , , Virginia, USA Death 1875 in , Lincoln, West Virginia, USA

5. Reuben Dick Birth 1830

6. Lafayette Dick Birth 1832

7. Notley Dick Birth 1833 in , , Virginia, USA

8. Joseph Dick Birth 1837

9. Mary Dick Birth 1837

10. Polly Dick Birth 1840

11. America Dick Birth 1844

Children of Joseph Dick and Catherine Cook:

1. Frances J Dick Birth 21 Feb 1844 in Boone, Franklin, Virginia, USA Death 1920 in Mile, Cabell, West Virginia, USA

2. Rhoda Dick Birth 1849 Death 1885

3. Benjamin Dick Birth 1851 Death 1928 in , Cabell, West Virginia, USA

4. Ballard Dick (male) Birth 1852 Death 17 Nov 1900 in Huntington, Cabell, West Virginia, USA

5. Cassander Spurkock or Spurlock Dick (male) Birth 1854 in Boone, Franklin, Virginia, USA

6. Margaret Ellen Dick Birth 4 May 1856 Death in Bradyville, Lincoln, West Virginia, USA

7. Henry Jasper Dick Birth Oct 1857 in , Cabell, West Virginia, USA Death 28 Jul 1945 in , Lincoln, West Virginia, USA

8. Catherine Dick Birth 5 Jun 1859 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA

9. David Dick Birth 1862 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA Death 1900



This family tree shows that Catherine Cook had previous marriage before she was married to Joseph Dick, and that her first husband was Hiriam Cremeans – but I disproved this marriage. Please see the notes below . . .

_______________________________________________________________________



“CLEDA R STEPHENS FAMILY RESEARCH” family tree, submitted by ancestry.com user “Cleda45” of Cabell County, West Virginia:

“Andrew Jackson Dick Birth 1827 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA, 1851, 1st Marriage to Cynthia A Leonard 2 Jan 1851 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA, 2nd Marriage to Mary V Handley 28 Nov 1864 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA, Death 1880 in , Cabell, West Virginia, USA

Cynthia A Leonard Birth 1831 Death 23 Jun 1860 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA

Mary V Handley Birth 1844

Children of Cynthia A Leonard and Andrew Jackson Dick:

1. Anna E Dick Birth 1852 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA

2. Rufus A Dick Birth 1853 Death 28 Mar 1854

3. Morris F Dick Birth 1856 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA

4. Henry L Dick Birth 14 Feb 1857 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA Death 20 Apr 1916

Children of Mary V Handley and Andrew Jackson Dick:

1. Lena E Dick Birth 1867

2. Ida A Dick Birth 1869”

_______________________________________________________________________



“CLEDA R STEPHENS FAMILY RESEARCH” family tree, submitted by ancestry.com user “Cleda45” of Cabell County, West Virginia:

“Solomon Cook, son of Peter Cook and Mary Carpenter, Birth 24 Feb 1783 in , Culpeper, Virginia, USA, Marriage to Sarah J Smith 7 Jun 1804 in Cabell, , Virginia, USA, Residence 1850 in District 10, Cabell, Virginia, Death 1850 in Cabel, , West Virginia, USA

Sarah J Smith, daughter of Cabell County Smith (father) and unknown mother, Birth 1790 in Culpepper, , Virginia, USA, Residence 1850 District 10, Cabell, Virginia , Death 1870 in Cabel, , West Virginia, USA

Children of Solomon Cook and Sarah J. Smith:

1. Mary Carpenter Cook Birth 15 Sep 1811

2. John Adam Cook Birth 17 Jun 1813

3. Peter Henry Cook Birth 5 Jun 1815

4. Nancy Jane Cook Birth 1816 in Mason, Logan, Virginia, USA Death 1 Feb 1855 in , Wise, Virginia, USA

5. Sarah Elizabeth Cook Birth 3 Feb 1818

6. James W Cook Birth 1820 in , Mason, West Virginia, USA

7. Catherine Cook, Marriage to Joseph Dick, Burial Aft 1880 in Cabell Co WV”

______________________________________________________________________



www.ancestry.com, Virginia Marriages, 1740-1850:

“Groom Name: Reuben Butcher

Bride Name: Rachael Dick

Marriage Date: 1 Aug 1822

County: Cabell

State: Virginia”

____________________________________________________________________



Ancestry.com “OneWorldTree”:

“Rachael Dick Born: 1797

Spouse

Reuben Butcher, son of William Butcher, Born: 1797

Marriage: 1 Aug 1822 in Cabell, Virginia, USA

Children:

1. Rebecca Butcher F 1822

2. Emily Butcher F 1823, Marriage: 24 Nov 1850 in Cabell, Virginia, USA to Greenville Harrison (Born: 1816, Died: 1916)

3. Sarah Octavia Butcher F 1826

4. Ellen Butcher F 16 Jun 1833 in Barboursville, Cabell, Virginia, USA, Marriage: 16 Aug 1855 in Cabell, Virginia, USA to Charles W Shipe (Born: 1833 in Virginia, USA, Died: 1 Jan 1905 in Cabell, West Virginia, USA)

Children of Ellen Butcher and Charles W Shipe:

1. William A Shipe M 4 Oct 1856 in Cabell, Virginia, USA

2. Mary E Shipe F 8 Jun 1860 in Cabell, Virginia, USA

3. Ellen Shipe F 14 Dec 1861 in Cabell, West Virginia, USA

4. Infant Shipe M 8 Jun 1864

5. Robert A Shipe M 1867 in Cabell, West Virginia, USA

6. Ulysses Grant Shipe M 12 Aug 1872 in Barboursville, Cabell, West Virginia, USA”



_____________________________________________________________________



Eleanor Butcher Dick likely died between 1844 and 1850, because her youngest child, America Dick, was born about 1844. By 1860 her husband, John Joseph Dick, had remarried to Catherine. On the 1860 census John Joseph Dick and Catherine have several children: 17-yr-old Frances, 11-yr-old Rhoda, 10-yr-old Benjamin, 8-yr-old Ballard, 6-yr-old Spurlock, 4-yr-old Margaret, 3-yr-old Henry J., and 1-yr-old Catherine Dick. Because the eldest child, Frances, would have been born around 1843 (around the same time that Eleanor's daughter, America Dick was born, it is possible that Frances was a daughter from Catherine’s previous marriage). The 6-year gap between the two eldest children listed on the 1860 census (in addition to the very close spacing of all of the rest of the children), might also support the idea that Frances may not have been the biological daughter of John Joseph Dick. Assuming that 11-yr-old Rhoda Dick was the first child of John Joseph Dick and Catherine, we might estimate that John and Catherine were married sometime around 1847 to 1849. (And on the 1850 census Eleanor is not listed, and her children are living with several different families in Cabell County, Virginia). So it is likely that Eleanor died between 1844 and 1850.

*Note: throughout all of my research so far, Frances J. Dick lists her father as Joseph Dick. I have not been able to definitively prove or disprove if Joseph Dick was her biological father or not, but from census records it seems that he raised her and was considered her father. From the lack of evidence proving otherwise, I have listed her as a child of Joseph Dick and Catherine Cook in my genealogy file and will leave it that way unless I find other sources in the future that show otherwise.


___________________________________________________________________



Catherine was the second wife of John Joseph Dick, following the death of John Joseph Dick’s first wife, Eleanor Butcher. According to , “Cleda R Stephens Family Research” family tree, submitted by ancestry.com user “Cleda45” of Cabell County, West Virginia, Catherine Cook’s marriage to John Joseph Dick was also her second marriage, and Catherine was previously married to Hiram Cremeans. But I have disproved the marriage between Catherine (wife of John Joseph Dick) and Hiram Cremeans. Catherine was married to John Joseph Dick and was recorded as living with him on both the 1850 and 1860 censuses, as shown below. Catherine, wife of Hiram Cremeans, was also recorded as living with Hiram and their children on both the 1850 and 1860 censuses, therefore, this could not be the same Catherine. As far as I can tell, the Cremeans family is not related to the Dick family at all:


1850 census: Katherine (age 30) and Joseph (age 50) Dick living in Boone County, Virginia with children: Frances J age 7, and Rhoda A age 0



1850 census: Catherine (40 yr) and Hiram (39 yrs) Cremeans living in Cabell County, Virginia with children: Lewis age 18, Cyntha age 15, Minta age 13, Cathrin age 11, Hiram age 9, Wesley age 7, William age 5, and Burton age 2



1860 census: Catherine (age 40) and Joseph (age 60) Dick living in Cabell County, Virginia with children: Frances age 17, Rhoda age 11, Benjamin age 10, Ballard age 8, Spurlock age 6, Margaret age 4, Henry J age 3, and Catherine age 1



1860 census: Catharine (age 49) and Hiram (age 48) Cremeans living in Wayne County, Virginia with children: Cynthia age 23, Minta age 21, Catharine age 20, Hiram age 18, Wesley age 16, William age 14, and Burten age 12

(census records found on www.ancestry.com)

___________________________________________________________________



, 1840 United States Federal Census, [city not stated], Cabell County, Virginia, ancestry.com image 49:

“Name of Head of Family: Joseph Dick

Free White Persons - Males - Under 5: 2

Free White Persons - Males - 5 thru 9: 2

Free White Persons - Males - 10 thru 14: 2

Free White Persons - Males - 15 thru 19: 2

Free White Persons - Males - 40 thru 49: 1

Free White Persons - Females - Under 5: 1

Free White Persons - Females - 30 thru 39: 1

Free Colored Persons: 0

Total - All Persons (Free White, Free Colored, Slaves): 11

Persons Employed in Agriculture: 6

White Persons over 20 Who Cannot Read and Write: 1

Free White Persons - Under 20: 9

Free White Persons - 20 thru 49: 2

Total Free White Persons: 11”



From what we know so far, in 1840 Joseph and Eleanor Dick’s family would have consisted of:


John Joseph Dick, age 40


Eleanor Butcher Dick, age 37


David Dick, age 16


Notley T. Dick, age 15


Andrew Jackson Dick, age 13


Reuben Dick, age 10


(possibly) Polly Dick, age 9 (or a baby)


Lafayette Dick, age 8


Morris Dick, age 4


Mary Dick, age 3


(possibly) Joseph Dick, age 3 (or not yet born)

____________________________________________________________________



, 1850 United States Federal Census, District 6, Boone County, Virginia, ancestry.com images 40 & 41, 5 August 1850, Dwelling No. 275, Family No. 275, Lines 40-42 & Line 1:

“Page 40:

Line 40, Joseph Dick, age 50, male, occupation: Laborer, born in Virginia.

Line 41, Katharine Dick, age 30, female, born in Virginia, cannot read and write.

Line 42, Frances J Dick, age 7, female, born in Virginia.

Page 41:

Line 1, Rhoda A Dick, age 7/12, female, born in Virginia.”

____________________________________________________________________



Because "Boone County was formed from an act of the Virginia General Assembly on March 11, 1847 from Cabell, Kanawha, and Logan counties," it is possible that John Joseph Dick never moved from his previous home in Cabell County, Virginia, but that the county boundaries were just changed around him??? (Not sure if he moved or not).

(Boone County History, )

__________________________________________________________________



, 1860 United States Federal Census, [city not stated], Cabell County, Virginia, ancestry.com image 89, 30 June 1860, Dwelling No. 733, Family No. 724, Lines 16-25:

“Line 16, Joseph Dick, age 60, male, occupation: Farmer, personal estate value: 50, born in Virginia.

Line 17, Catherine Dick, age 40, female, born in Virginia, unable to read and write.

Line 18, Frances Dick, age 17, female, born in Virginia, attended school within the year.

Line 19, Rhoda Dick, age 11, female, born in Virginia, attended school within the year.

Line 20, Benjamin Dick, age 10, male, born in Virginia, attended school within the year.

Line 21, Ballard Dick, age 8, male, born in Virginia, attended school within the year.

Line 22, Spurlock Dick, age 6, male, born in Virginia.

Line 23, Margaret Dick, age 4, female, born in Virginia.

Line 24, Henry J Dick, age 3, male, born in Virginia.

Line 25, Catherine Dick, age 1, female, born in Virginia.”

No comments:

Post a Comment